The Content Treadmill: Why Posting Randomly Doesn’t Work
The Content Treadmill: Why Posting Randomly Doesn’t Work
In 2023, we worked with a retail client who came to us frustrated. They were spending hours each week posting on Instagram and Facebook, hoping for traction. Some weeks they’d share five posts in a row. Other weeks, nothing at all. Engagement was unpredictable, sales didn’t shift, and morale in the team was sinking.
They weren’t lazy — in fact, they were working harder than ever. But they had fallen into what we call the content treadmill: creating content for content’s sake, without strategy or direction.
The Problem With Random Posting
When businesses post sporadically — without a plan, consistent style, or message — three things usually happen:
-
The audience gets confused. Customers see mixed messages, inconsistent visuals, and no clear brand identity.
-
The algorithm doesn’t help. Social platforms reward consistency and clarity. If you disappear for weeks, your reach collapses.
-
The team burns out. Without a plan, content creation feels like a chore, not a business driver.
Our client was seeing all three. Their follower count had stalled, their sales were flat, and their marketing manager was exhausted.
The Turning Point
Instead of telling them to simply “post more”, we built a strategic content calendar. Together we defined:
-
Core themes that aligned with their brand values
-
A posting rhythm they could realistically sustain
-
Design templates to ensure every post looked professional
-
Metrics to track performance beyond just likes (sales enquiries, website clicks, repeat customers)
Within three months, their engagement had doubled. Website traffic from social rose by 48%. Most importantly, they finally understood why they were posting — and what results to expect.
The Lesson
Consistency beats bursts of effort. Random posting creates noise, while strategic posting builds momentum.
A clear plan delivers:
-
A recognisable brand voice and style
-
Better algorithm visibility
-
A calmer, more confident team
-
Measurable impact on leads and sales
Final Word
Social media is a powerful growth tool — but only if it’s approached with structure. The content treadmill drains energy and rarely produces results.
If you’re posting without a plan and seeing little return, it’s not because social media doesn’t work for your industry. It’s because you need strategy. At Veritas UI, we help businesses break out of the treadmill and build systems that deliver consistent, measurable growth.